Home > Food Media, Making Food > In Defense Of Sandra Lee’s Lasagna

In Defense Of Sandra Lee’s Lasagna

Poor Sandra Lee – not so long ago, she was the darling of the Food Network, and queen of her own little corner of the culinary universe in which she was free to conceive of whatever crazy “semi-homemade” concoctions she could think of.   At worst, some negative reviews would appear on her recipe pages at Foodtv.com, but they would usually be outweighed by the positive ones.

*Note: lest there be confusion, the dish pictured on the right is not her lasagna – it is non-traditional but it is not THAT non-traditional….

But now, by virtue of her relationship with Andrew Cuomo, she finds herself and her cooking suddenly thrust into the harsh glare of the national media.  Suddenly, the press are crawling all over her books and recipes, questioning her media savvy, and to add insult to injury, her boyfriend’s Italian mamma disses her lasagna recipe in the presence of TV reporters (for the recipe itself, go here).

So it has come to this, the New York Times itself has decided to jump on the pile and has devoted a snarky edition of its Diner’s Journal to “Putting Sandra Lee’s Lasagna To The Test.” Ultimately, the journal reports that the resulting dish is “cafeteria-style” and “ketchuppy” but concludes “we’ve had worse.”  Fair enough.  It should be noted that her recipe calls for cottage cheese and also for canned tomato soup as the sauce, hardly traditional ingredients.

Sandra’s recipe has evidently stirred the passions of Times readers, who state their opinions on the matter in no uncertain terms in the comments:

For example, commentor “ORL” is not afraid to wear his emotions on his sleeve:

I’ll never forget the day I went to a friend’s house in grade school and her mom served us spaghetti – Chef Boyardee from a can. I started crying! It was unrecognizable.

Next, “Smitty” lowers the boom:

I grew up in the Midwest, and even there this wouldn’t have passed as lasagne.

In contrast, “Jack” cuts to the chase very efficiently:

Sandra Lee was being PAID by Campbell’s to promote their product, in this case tomato soup. Get it?

As an aside, did anyone ever think that maybe, just maybe, Andrew Cuomo wasn’t dating Sandra Lee for her cooking ability?

And then we have commentor “Stephen:”

I must say that to me, lasagna is a two day process (and no, I’m not Italian). The first day, you make your Bolognese sauce and let it simmer all day (rich with white wine, milk, pork, veal, beef, mirepoix). Then, you make your bechamel and you assemble the lasagna. It rests overnight before being baked the next day, when all of the flavors have had a chance to harmonize. Time consuming? Yes. Worth it? Absolutely.

Now, I’m sure “Stephen” makes a MARVELOUS lasagna, but we are really comparing apples to oranges at this point.  To his credit, he is actually constructive and avoids the condescension and half-assed culinary “moralizing” that is found throughout these comments.  But Sandra Lee’s recipe is not for those home cooks that will lovingly craft a “two-day” lasagna in the style that “Stephen” suggests.  To the contrary, it is meant to be quick and easy in all aspects of its preparation.

Now, honestly, her recipe sounds kind of gross to me, and I am in no hurry to rush out and replicate it, even for the sake of journalism.  However, my intention is to defend the spirit of the recipe, which is (as I understand it), a quick and easy lasagna made out of simple and readily available ingredients.  But what I disagree with is the notion that somehow lasagna MUST be lengthy, laborious, made with only the freshest, homemade ingredients, and so on.  It may be best that way, but frankly, it is not always feasible to make it that way.

So, taking a page from “Stephen’s” book, I will attempt to provide a constructive alternative by providing my own “quick and easy” lasagna recipe, rather than just going through more comments and raking certain commentors across the coals in true anonymous blogger style, as I was originally planning on doing.  So, if Sandra’s recipe does not appeal, try this – it has even fewer ingredients than hers. 

1 28 oz. can crushed tomatoes
2 pkgs. frozen spinach
1 pkg. “no boil” lasagna noodles
3-4 fresh sweet Italian sausages, best quality you can find
1 lb. shredded mozzarella cheese (or chopped into very small cubes)
1 cup grated parmesan

1.  remove sausage from casing, form into bite-size pieces and brown in a pan
2.  strain crushed tomatoes thoroughly.  If using “no boil” noodles, add a 1/2 cup of water back to the tomato mixture.
3.  microwave the spinach packages to defrost, then drain any excess liquid.
4.  Construct the lasagna in an appropriately sized pan, you don’t really need instructions for this part, do you? Just make sure the layers of spinach/sausage/sauce/cheese come out even
5.  Cover the pan tightly with tin foil
6.  Bake at 350 for 30 minutes.

*some notes:
 –   Don’t be afraid of the “no-boil” noodles, they are just dry noodles that cook in sauce instead of boiling water.  So don’t be anxious if the sauce seems watery, it will end up being absorbed.
 – fresh mozarella is fine to use, but it will produce more water so be aware. 
 – the sauce can obviously be enhanced by adding some garlic, olive oil, fresh basil, etc.  – if you have time.
 – you could also add some ricotta as well, but I would not substitute it entirely for mozzarella as it basically just turns to liquid
 – if for some reason the noodles do not cook entirely, you can always just add some water, re-seal and cook for a while longer. But this is unlikely to happen.

This is not a highbrow recipe, but it gets the job done.  It is easy to shop for, quick to prepare (certainly it should take no longer than Sandra’s recipe), and tastes good.  There is no shame in cooking recipes like this – while you might not want to serve the dish at a fancy dinner party, it makes a hearty and satisfying dinner that will serve several people, and probably provide some leftovers.

  1. Michelle
    June 29, 2010 at 3:22 PM

    Her recipe calls for 2 cans of tomato soup. I think each serving of tomato soup is 30% of your RDA of sodium, multiplied by 2.5 servings per can * 2 cans = 150% of your RDA of sodium, before taking into account CHEESE, PASTA, AND MEAT. GROSS.

    • June 30, 2010 at 4:06 PM

      Agreed, Michelle. As J. Frankfurter’s recipe demonstrates, it really isn’t that hard to prepare lasagna using packaged products. There is nothing wrong with using packaged products every once in awhile since we all live very busy lives. We take issue with which packaged products Ms. Lee utilizes.

  1. No trackbacks yet.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: